Posted in:

Comparing WYSIWYG PDF Editors: Which One Provides the Best User Experience?

© by Lee Campbell for Unsplash+

WYSIWYG editors have become essential tools in content creation and web design. Short for What You See Is What You Get, these editors enable users to develop content visually (e.g., it allows you to create sophisticated layouts or rich text without having to touch the underlying code). Among these, WYSIWYG PDF editors have carved out a niche, allowing users to edit a pdf as easily. But how do these WYSIWYG editors compare to one another — which editor provides the best experience? 

The Rise of the WYSIWYG PDF Editor

PDF files are popular for distributing documents that need to maintain their formatting (printed documents) across different platforms and devices. However, editing them becomes difficult without the proper tools. To resolve this problem, the WYSIWYG PDF editor offers a way for users to interactively edit their PDFs directly by manipulating images and text fields, as easily as they would in a word processor. It has become a critical tool for anyone who routinely uses PDFs in their profession.

Criteria for Comparison

Let’s go through a few critical criteria to compare the different WYSIWYG editors:

  • User-Friendly: How easy is the interface to use? Is there a high learning curve?
  • Features: What functionalities are provided? Are there limitations to what you can create or edit?
  • Performance: How will the software operate with large files or complicated documents?
  • Supported Files: What file types and tools can this editor work with?
  • Support and Community: Can you get help when needed? How active is the community around this editor?

Popular WYSIWYG Editors

Adobe Acrobat Pro DC

Adobe Acrobat Pro DC is a powerful WYSIWYG PDF editor known for its comprehensive feature set. This software will let users edit or retrieve text and images in a PDF file, convert PDF to other formats, add interactive elements (such forms), etc. It is a foremost choice for professionals because of its integration with other Adobe products. However, its extensive features come with a higher price tag, meaning that it could be overwhelming for people on a limited budget.

TinyMCE

TinyMCE is a web-based WYSIWYG editor used in many major content management systems. It is famous for its simplicity and useful integration with almost all other platforms. Though not intended for editing PDFs, this is fantastic to create HTML content that can then be converted to PDF. Being an open-source software, there’s a big community for support as well. If you are good with coding, then this tool boast flexibility at its best. 

CKEditor

CKEditor is another popular web-based editor with a clean interface and powerful content creation functionalities. This one is good for teams as it allows collaboration and commenting. Otherwise, like TinyMCE, this software is not created specifically for PDFs. Still, it can be used to compile content intended for the PDF format. It comes with a very large community and tons of documentation as well.

Froala

What sets Froala apart is its more contemporary interface and focus on ease of use. This newbie-friendly tool also has features that even the most seasoned developer will surely appreciate. Though it is more targeted towards HTML content, you can still use this as a base for document creation before converting them to PDF. Froala is lightweight and fast, which makes it perfect for applications that require a high load speed.

Quill

Quill is an open-source WYSIWYG editor; it is simple and fast. Quill is designed to be easily extensible using modern web technologies. Though it can’t edit native PDFs, it is great for drafting documents that will then be exported to PDF. The good thing about it is its developer-friendly API, which is a plus for custom implementations. 

Conclusion

While considering a WYSIWYG Editor in terms of UX, it mostly depends on the specific user needs. If you want more robust editing, then a dedicated WYSIWYG PDF editor like Adobe Acrobat Pro DC may be worth considering, even with its high price and complexity level. TinyMCE, CKEditor, Froala, and others are great for web content that will be exported to PDF at some point, and they scale fairly well between ease of use and a wide range of features. 

In the end, it really comes down to what better supports your workflow, project’s needs, and skill level.