Posted in:

Analyzing the Winning Trends of Super Bowl Champions

Over time, trends in Super Bowl winners have revealed interesting patterns. These patterns have seen shifts between offensive and defensive dominance, periods of mediocrity, and eras of imbalance, among others. This article delves into understanding these trends and what they mean for future favorites to win the Super Bowl.

A Look Back at Super Bowl History

The Super Bowl, a championship game in the National Football League (NFL), has witnessed a plethora of teams clinching the coveted Lombardi Trophy. The performance trends these teams displayed have considerably changed over the years. To begin this analysis, we will revisit some distinct eras that have emerged.

Defensive Dominance: 2000-2005

In the early 2000s, the mantra, “Defense wins championships,” was quite apt. The Super Bowl champions of this time had their defense ranked significantly higher than their offense. Teams like the 2000 Ravens, 2002 Buccaneers, and 2003 Patriots, with their defenses ranked No. 1, exemplify this trend.

The Era of Mediocrity: 2006-2015

Jumping ahead to the mid-2000s, we find ourselves in a time when the typical Super Bowl champion had a points per game (PPG) ranking that hovered around the middle of the league (10.5) for both scored and allowed. Teams such as the 2007 and 2011 Giants, who had some of the worst combined rankings, symbolize this era. 

Offensive Reign: 2017-Present

The current era seems to underscore the statement, “Offense wins championships!” From 2017 onwards, Super Bowl champions have boasted higher offensive rankings than defensive ones, with teams like the 2022 Chiefs (No. 1 in offense) leading the charge.

Unfolding the Era of Imbalance: 2000-Present

The new millennium ushered in an era of extremes. The gap between offensive and defensive ranks widened considerably. It’s interesting to note that the 2006 Colts and 2008 Steelers, despite their starkly differing strengths, both emerged victorious.

The Era of Dominance: 1970-1999

The pre-2000 era was characterized by consistently high-performing offenses and defenses. The Super Bowl winners in this period, with an average rank of 4.2, were more dominant than their successors in the 21st century.

A Closer Look at Offensive and Defensive Trends

Analyzing the trends further, we notice a clear shift in the importance of offense versus defense in winning championships.

The Rise of Offense

The importance of a strong offense has increased over time. The 1990s and the current era both emphasize the importance of a top-tier offensive unit. 

Defense Still Crucial

Despite the offensive shift, a strong defense remains crucial. The importance of defense in winning championships is evidenced by the fact that 13 Super Bowl winners since the merger were ranked No. 1 in total defense.

The Balance between Offense and Defense

While the debate about whether offense or defense wins championships continues, the importance of striking a balance cannot be overlooked. As the analysis shows, only eight Super Bowl winners since the merger had an average rank of 10th or worse for offense and defense combined. This highlights the need for both a potent offense and a robust defense.

The Role of Power Dynamics

Apart from on-field performance, power dynamics within a team also play a significant role. The balance of power between the coach and the team management often influences the team’s path to victory.

Lessons from the Past

Analyzing past trends is essential for making informed Super Bowl predictions. While these trends help us understand the game’s changing dynamics, it’s crucial to remember they are not always predictive. The ever-evolving nature of the sport ensures that new patterns will continue to emerge.

Towards the Future

Keeping in mind these trends and the constant evolution of the game, predicting future Super Bowl champions remains a complex task. However, these patterns do provide some insight into the traits that successful teams commonly exhibit.


In summary, the trends of Super Bowl champions have varied over the years, with shifts between offense and defense dominance and periods of mediocrity and imbalance. These trends provide an interesting insight into the game’s evolution and what it takes to become the favorite to win the Super Bowl. However, the unpredictable nature of the sport means new patterns will continue to emerge.