Posted in:

Designing Behavioral Assessment: Best Practices for Recruiters

A behavioral assessment is now a key part of modern hiring methods. It helps recruiters understand candidates’ behavior and how well they might fit into a company’s culture. Unlike old-fashioned ways that rely on personal opinions, a behavioral assessment gives a clear way to look at candidates’ traits and skills. By seeing how candidates deal with real situations, recruiters can better guess how they’ll do. 

This means working with others to determine what skills are important, picking the right tests, and making scenarios that show what candidates might face in the job. It’s also important to make sure the tests are fair and reliable. Adding a test to assess behavioral management skills to hiring helps recruiters understand candidates better and keeps things fairer. 

Steps to design a behavioral assessment

Behavioral assessment has become an indispensable tool in modern recruitment practices. Here are seven best practices for recruiters to effectively design and implement a behavioral assessment:

Understanding the purpose of a behavioral assessment:

A behavioral assessment predicts a candidate’s job performance by evaluating their behaviors, traits, and competencies. Unlike traditional interviews that rely on subjective impressions, a behavioral assessment provides structured insights into how candidates will likely respond to real-world situations.

Identifying essential competencies:

Collaboration with stakeholders is crucial in identifying the core competencies required for success in a particular role. Through job analysis techniques, recruiters can pinpoint the behaviors and skills associated with high performance, thereby guiding the design of assessment criteria.

Choosing the right behavioral assessment methods:

Recruiters should select behavioral assessment methods that align with the identified competencies. Situational judgment tests, behavioral interviews, and psychometric assessments are commonly used tools, each offering unique advantages in assessing behavioral traits and skills.

Designing scenarios and questions:

The scenarios and questions presented in a behavioral assessment should reflect the challenges candidates will likely encounter in the role. These scenarios need to be specific, relevant, and tailored to assess the desired competencies effectively.

Ensuring validity and reliability:

Before implementation, behavioral assessment tools must undergo pilot testing to ensure validity and reliability. Validation studies help establish the accuracy of the assessment in predicting job performance, while reliability measures ensure consistent results.

Integrating the behavioral assessment into the recruitment process:

Seamlessly incorporating a behavioral assessment into the recruitment process helps maintain candidate engagement and minimizes fatigue. Clear communication regarding the purpose and format of assessment is essential to ensure candidates understand what is expected of them.

Evaluating candidate responses:

Recruiters should develop a scoring rubric or evaluation framework aligned with the predefined competencies. Objective assessment of candidate responses, focusing on observable behaviors, helps differentiate between strong and weak performers.

Effective implementation of a behavioral assessment

Implementing a behavioral assessment in hiring needs careful planning. Here are seven steps to make it work:

Find important skills:

Start by figuring out the key skills needed for the job. Work with others to understand what behaviors make someone successful in the role. This helps in creating the right criteria for assessment.

Choose the right rests:

Pick tests that match the skills you’ve identified. There are different kinds of tests, such as interviews or tests that measure personality. Choose what fits best for the job and company.

Create relevant scenarios and questions:

Make scenarios and questions that resemble real situations in the job. They should be clear and directly linked to the skills being tested. This helps get a good idea of how candidates might perform on the job.

Check if the tests are good.

Before using any behavioral assessment, measure what they’re supposed to. Test them out to see if they give consistent results. Add the behavioral assessment smoothly into the hiring process so candidates are not overwhelmed. Tell candidates why they’re being tested and what’s expected of them.

Train recruiters and managers:

Teach recruiters and managers how to use the tests well and understand the results. Show them how to conduct interviews and score candidate answers. This helps in picking the best candidates fairly.

Integrating logical and verbal reasoning tests with behavioral assessment

Integrating a logical reasoning test and a verbal reasoning test with a behavioral assessment can give a complete picture of candidates’ abilities and traits for a job. Here are five steps to mix these tests into the hiring process:

Matching tests with skills needed:

Start by figuring out the skills and qualities needed for the job. Work with others to decide which skills are best tested with a test to assess logical reasoning skills, verbal reasoning test, and a behavioral assessment. Make sure the tests line up with what’s required for the job.

Picking the right tests:

Choose a logical reasoning test and a verbal reasoning test that accurately measures candidates’ problem-solving, thinking, and communication skills. Think about how complex the job is when choosing the tests. Also, pick a behavioral assessment that goes well with the logical and verbal reasoning tests. 

Creating combined scenarios:

Make scenarios for tests that mix logical reasoning test, verbal reasoning test and behavior assessment elements. These should reflect real work situations where candidates need to think and communicate. Ensure candidates can show their skills and behaviors, like teamwork or leadership.

Keeping things fair:

Set clear rules for scoring each part of the combined tests to keep things fair. Train recruiters on how to give tests and score them without bias. Give guidelines on using test results and other factors when deciding whether candidates fit the job.

Understanding test results:

Look at results from all three-logical reasoning tests, verbal reasoning tests, and behavioral assessments together to understand candidates better. See if there’s a connection between how well candidates do on logical and verbal reasoning tests and their behaviors. Use test results to make better hiring choices and ask interview questions that dig deeper into candidates’ suitability for the job.

By mixing logical and the test to assess verbal reasoning skills with a behavioral assessment, companies can better understand candidates’ skills and behaviors, helping them make smarter hiring decisions and find the right people for the job.


Adding a behavioral assessment to hiring is important. It helps find candidates who not only have the right skills but also the right behaviors for the job. By matching assessments with what’s needed, choosing the right tests, and giving helpful feedback, recruiters can get a good idea of how well candidates fit the job. 

Also, using a logical reasoning test and a verbal reasoning test alongside a behavioral assessment gives a better understanding of candidates’ thinking skills. It all helps make better hiring choices. 

Transform your hiring process with Testlify’s advanced test to assess behavioral skills. Gain valuable insights into candidates’ behaviors and skills to build high-performing teams. Elevate your recruitment strategy today and unlock the potential of your workforce with Testlify. Try it now!